https://bugs.freedesktop.org/show_bug.cgi?id=99815

Bug ID: 99815 Summary: Power management problems & kernel hangs with Cap Verde Product: DRI Version: unspecified Hardware: Other OS: Linux (All) Status: NEW Severity: normal Priority: medium Component: DRM/AMDgpu Assignee: dri-devel@lists.freedesktop.org Reporter: klaus.kusche@computerix.info

I recently switched from the radeon kernel driver to the amdgpu kernel driver. As a consequence, battery lifetime of my laptop was more than halved (before I could give *two* 90 minutes lectures in a row running on battery, now the battery is empty after around 70 minutes), i.e. with amdgpu, the graphic card consumes a multiple of the power it needed with radeon.

GPU is AMDGPU(0): Chipset: "VERDE" (ChipID = 0x6825) Laptop is Dell Precision M6700 OS is linux 4.9, userland is running latest official releases (Gentoo) Typical load is two screens (internal + VGA-Beamer, both 1024x768 mirrored) with very light load (no 3D & no video at all, just static pdf slides).

Power settings in battery mode with the old radeon driver were * no dpm (always was very unstable and consumed by far more power than "classic" pm) * "classic" pm with power_method = profile and power_profile = low

Analysis of the problems with amdgpu showed:

1.) There is no "classic" power management: If dpm is turned off with amdgpu, there is no power management at all, and the card permanently runs with high power. Why was "classic" power management dropped completely?

Basically, I neither want nor need any dynamic adjustment: When on battery, the gpu should permanently run on minimal power, independent of its load.

2.) The default dpm mode is "balanced" and "auto". "balanced" does not change to "battery" automatically when AC is removed, and it is impossible to set the mode to "battery" manually: Any attempt to set it via sysfs either kills the process doing so or hangs it in a kill-9-immune state (which prevents system shutdown).

I then code-changed the default initialization in si_dpm.c from "balanced" to "battery". This hangs the whole kernel hard during early boot: No display, no reaction to Alt-Sysrq, ... only hard power off helps.

3.) It is possible to set the dpm level from "auto" to "low", but that does not seem to result in any measurable effect or power savings?