Hello Sir/Madam,
I am trying to render some stuff using DRM with Qt GUI application and decoded stream from Intel H/w decoder.
I have two applications one is for GUI content and another one is for decoded video streams. While doing this I am facing an issue that only singal process acquires DRM mastership while the other one is getting error.
While wondering how to get the privilege to render stuff I came across GET_MAGIC and AUTH_MAGIC. Please refer to this text from the MAN page of DRM.
All DRM devices provide authentication mechanisms. Only a DRM-Master is
allowed to perform mode-setting or modify core state and only one user can be DRM-Master at a time. See drmSetMaster https://www.commandlinux.com/man-page/man3/drmSetMaster.3.html(3) for information on how to become DRM-Master and what the limitations are. Other DRM users can be authenticated to the DRM-Master via drmAuthMagic https://www.commandlinux.com/man-page/man3/drmAuthMagic.3.html(3) so they can perform buffer allocations and rendering.
As per this the client which is authenticated using magic code should be able to allocate buffer and rendering. But while doing this I am not able to use drmModeSetPlane() for rendering stuff on display from an authenticated client application. It is giving me Permission Denied.
As per my understanding if the client is authenticated by using GET/AUTH_MAGIC it should be able to set a plane and render stuff on the display.
Is my understanding correct? Can we use this method to simultaneously render from two applications?
Thank you in advance.
Having Addiction of Self-Dependence
*Hardik Panchal* SDT - Satatya Devices Contact No. : 9924472937 Email : hardik23398@gmail.com
On Thu, 4 Mar 2021 09:43:22 +0530 Hardik Panchal hardik.panchal@matrixcomsec.com wrote:
Hello Sir/Madam,
I am trying to render some stuff using DRM with Qt GUI application and decoded stream from Intel H/w decoder.
I have two applications one is for GUI content and another one is for decoded video streams. While doing this I am facing an issue that only singal process acquires DRM mastership while the other one is getting error.
Hi,
yes, this is deliberate and by design.
The idea of having two separate processes simultaneously controlling KMS planes of the same CRTC is fundamentally forbidden. Even if it was not forbidden, doing so would lead to other technical problems.
You have to change your architecture so that only one process controls KMS. It you need other processes, they have to pass buffers or rendering commands to the process that does control KMS. In other words, you need a display server.
While wondering how to get the privilege to render stuff I came across GET_MAGIC and AUTH_MAGIC. Please refer to this text from the MAN page of DRM.
Those will not help you with breaking the DRM master concept.
All DRM devices provide authentication mechanisms. Only a DRM-Master is allowed to perform mode-setting or modify core state and only one user can be DRM-Master at a time. See drmSetMaster https://www.commandlinux.com/man-page/man3/drmSetMaster.3.html(3) for information on how to become DRM-Master and what the limitations are. Other DRM users can be authenticated to the DRM-Master via drmAuthMagic https://www.commandlinux.com/man-page/man3/drmAuthMagic.3.html(3) so they can perform buffer allocations and rendering.
As per this the client which is authenticated using magic code should be able to allocate buffer and rendering. But while doing this I am not able to use drmModeSetPlane() for rendering stuff on display from an authenticated client application. It is giving me Permission Denied.
As per my understanding if the client is authenticated by using GET/AUTH_MAGIC it should be able to set a plane and render stuff on the display.
No. Authentication gives access to buffer allocation and submitting rendering commands to the GPU. It does not give access to KMS.
Sorry, pq
On Fri, Mar 05, 2021 at 05:44:04PM +0200, Pekka Paalanen wrote:
On Thu, 4 Mar 2021 09:43:22 +0530 Hardik Panchal hardik.panchal@matrixcomsec.com wrote:
Hello Sir/Madam,
I am trying to render some stuff using DRM with Qt GUI application and decoded stream from Intel H/w decoder.
I have two applications one is for GUI content and another one is for decoded video streams. While doing this I am facing an issue that only singal process acquires DRM mastership while the other one is getting error.
Hi,
yes, this is deliberate and by design.
The idea of having two separate processes simultaneously controlling KMS planes of the same CRTC is fundamentally forbidden. Even if it was not forbidden, doing so would lead to other technical problems.
You have to change your architecture so that only one process controls KMS. It you need other processes, they have to pass buffers or rendering commands to the process that does control KMS. In other words, you need a display server.
One option is kms leases, where the main compositor with exclusive control over the display can pass a select set of resources to another process. But it's a clear lessor/lessee relationship, and the main compositor can always revoke the lease if needed. -Daniel
While wondering how to get the privilege to render stuff I came across GET_MAGIC and AUTH_MAGIC. Please refer to this text from the MAN page of DRM.
Those will not help you with breaking the DRM master concept.
All DRM devices provide authentication mechanisms. Only a DRM-Master is allowed to perform mode-setting or modify core state and only one user can be DRM-Master at a time. See drmSetMaster https://www.commandlinux.com/man-page/man3/drmSetMaster.3.html(3) for information on how to become DRM-Master and what the limitations are. Other DRM users can be authenticated to the DRM-Master via drmAuthMagic https://www.commandlinux.com/man-page/man3/drmAuthMagic.3.html(3) so they can perform buffer allocations and rendering.
As per this the client which is authenticated using magic code should be able to allocate buffer and rendering. But while doing this I am not able to use drmModeSetPlane() for rendering stuff on display from an authenticated client application. It is giving me Permission Denied.
As per my understanding if the client is authenticated by using GET/AUTH_MAGIC it should be able to set a plane and render stuff on the display.
No. Authentication gives access to buffer allocation and submitting rendering commands to the GPU. It does not give access to KMS.
Sorry, pq
dri-devel mailing list dri-devel@lists.freedesktop.org https://lists.freedesktop.org/mailman/listinfo/dri-devel
dri-devel@lists.freedesktop.org
-
Daniel Vetter -
Hardik Panchal -
Pekka Paalanen